Are Progressives Smarter Than Fifth Graders?

Published in Articles, RealClearPolitics

May 19, 2011–Personal political preferences can be a mysterious thing. Are progressives simply born that way, springing forth fully formed like Athena from Zeus’s head, thoughts of social justice and monorails imprinted on their psyches? Or are they slowly molded, surrounded by lectures about fairness, National Public Radio, and frequent viewings of “Avatar”?

Joe Kernen, host of CNBC’s “Squawk Box,” believes the latter is true — and he’s not growing any liberals at his house, thank you very much. His new book, “Your Teacher Said WHAT?!,” chronicles Kernen’s efforts to defend his fifth-grade daughter and co-author, Blake, “from the liberal assault on capitalism.”

Ah, Blake. Poor, innocent Blake. I have to admit I felt kind of bad for her at certain points of the book, given that as a reader, I was subjected to the same lectures that she undoubtedly received ad nauseum over the past two years. (Sorry, Joe — your intentions are good, I know. My husband regularly lectures our children on deep philosophical questions, and they’re still in Pampers. Thus far, they show no sign of favoring progressive ideas like state-subsidized cowboy poetry, but you never know — to a 2-year old, that idea might sound pretty compelling.)

And, as a matter of fact, that’s one of Kernen’s main arguments: Progressives, he writes, “retain a child’s view of the world. Like ten-year-olds, they retain a belief in obvious heroes and villains, in perfection as a place where things don’t change (especially as the result of human action), and in happy endings.” Progressives also tend to make Kernen’s head explode. “Progressivism,” he writes, “is a durable bit of craziness.” (Ouch, right? “So,” he admits, “is parenting.”)

Your Teacher Said WHAT?!” offers a laundry list of basic explanations for various progressive ills, most of which are, sadly, accurate: Our culture unfairly demonizes capitalism and business. Public employee unions have run amok. Government regulations come with unintended, sometimes destructive, consequences. The tax code is laughable. Both nature and hungry animals can be mean.

Other points, like Kernen’s breezy confidence in plentiful oil (and our ability to transition off of it) or his bashing of high-end/grass-fed/organic food (have you read a hamburger label lately? There’s meat from 11 countries in there), are more debatable. Those hoping for lurid tales of state-funded public school indoctrination, meanwhile, will be disappointed. (There are, however, some fairly entertaining dissections of anti-capitalist themes in children’s movies — in the movie “WALL-E,” Kernen points out, “Earth has been destroyed not by fire or by ice but by “Everyday Low Prices.”)

All quibbling aside, Kernen deserves credit for taking an active role in his children’s education and for seeking to help other parents do the same. Throughout his book, he challenges destructive anti-market assumptions passed on by our culture every day, and he’s often amusing while doing it.

Economic literacy is not a sexy topic, but it’s exceptionally important. Many economists, including Friedrich Hayek, author of “The Road to Serfdom,” have seen a strong link between state-controlled economies and the path to totalitarianism. On a less dramatic level, economic liberty — and the future generation’s embrace or dismissal of it — will significantly impact their standard of living, health care, and personal freedom. And on a global historical scale, as Kernen notes, many progressive ideas, when institutionalized, can lead to starvation, famine, or worse.

The facts tend to fall on the side of free markets. So why are there so many intelligent progressives out there? (And there are plenty. Though he takes a few shots at Harvard and Princeton, even Kernen won’t argue their resident liberals are dummies.) And what if, despite his daily dispensation of free market economics, Joe Kernen loses the war? What if his daughter Blake grows up to be — cue the Hollywood horror-movie screams — a liberal?

And, more importantly, what would inspire her to make that choice? The positions of progressives leave Kernen flummoxed: “It’s hard, if not impossible,” he writes, “to tell whether the positions taken by the New York Times are so consistently wrong out of ignorance, denial, or a deliberate attempt to gloss over problems that get in the way of the newspaper’s Progressive agenda (this is actually a problem with most Progressives). ”

Life, with its shades of gray, often frustrates the empiricist — and political persuasions are often about far more than facts. Kernen cites a psychological theory that divides people into two groups: ” ‘Internals’ believe that they are in control of their own lives, while ‘externals’ see themselves as subject to outside forces they can’t control.” Not shockingly, “externals” tend to be progressives — and cultural attitudes can influence and encourage this belief.

Smart people (and not just progressives, by the way) cling to dodgy ideas for all sorts of reasons. Some may give them a sense of identity. Some, like “humans bad, trees good” environmentalism, have an almost religious appeal. Some are powered by persuasive marketing.

And some ideas are so appealing on the surface that people, quite simply, just want them to be true. Facts alone won’t change their mind.

But offering a competing and positive vision might. It’s something that even a 10-year-old, thankfully, can understand.






Heather Wilhelm is a Chicago-based writer with experience in marketing, public relations, corporate communications, online news, web development, magazine editing, and print journalism. Her written commentary has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, RealClearPolitics.com, the Washington Examiner, and the National Review Online. She currently serves as a senior fellow at the Illinois Policy Institute.
To inquire about freelance work, other projects, or to join my distribution list, contact me at heather@heatherwilhelm.com.